12 Comments
User's avatar
Blair Fraipont's avatar

Now whenever I hear mushmouth (me, c. 2017) singing I usually tune out because at this point it's so worn out, I just lose interest in a singer. There's always exceptions. For whatever reason SZA's doesn't phase me maybe because she uses it like mild seasoning. Ultimately, I blame Arthur Russell and/or Karen Dalton (Godfather and Godmother of the googly-eyed clam singing). My loose theory is those remastered albums/compilations (circa '03 -'05) of both Russell and Dalton (more Russell in my guestimate) influenced artists like Devendra Banhart, other indie/new-folkie "weirdos," etc. who then influenced pop singers in the late 00's or early 2010s.

Expand full comment
Dave Moore's avatar

The McRae album might be the most....I want to say meta form of this singing I've come across, it's like she's trying to throw you off the scent that there are words in there somewhere

Expand full comment
Blair Fraipont's avatar

Bahahhaha... Damn... Now I wanna hear it.

Expand full comment
Dave Moore's avatar

The McRae album probably won't make any of my lists. There's just something about her singing that I find interesting in a way that most of the people using these affectations don't have, like someone who doesn't speak English creating a meta-mushmouth by *over*-enunciating poorly-enunciated singing. (I am almost certainly overselling it lol, just think the idea is funny.)

Expand full comment
Blair Fraipont's avatar

Yeah, I can handle this singing because the pop production keeps things nice and sugary. I think the more earnest or barebones the song or production is the more the mushmouth bothers me.

Expand full comment
Dave Moore's avatar

It's the difference between shoving pink slime in a breaded nugget form versus artfully plating it on its own

Expand full comment
Blair Fraipont's avatar

Well said, yes! (LOL)

Expand full comment
Dave Moore's avatar

Yes, I'm trying to get a better sense of where the vocal mannerisms came from that doesn't just punt to Amy Winehouse. I think indie, alt-singer-songwriter (Regina Spektor), and some YouTube Shit that I wasn't really paying attention to are all more promising, along with....maybe emo?

Expand full comment
Blair Fraipont's avatar

Yeah, I think the answer it comes from several places, not just, say, Arthur Russell. Not a musher, but on the same lines of looking for influential traits, I like to think that Adele was co-birthed by Lauryn Hill's "Ex-Factor."

Expand full comment
Blair Fraipont's avatar

Great mix, by the way. The penultimate track by Peni Candra Rini is almost Cathy Berberian-esque in it's composition-style? LOVE. IT!

Expand full comment
Steve Erickson's avatar

The second episode of "Radio Not Radio" is up now, featuring songs by Nayomi & Perrie and Vanyfox I learned about here: https://www.mixcloud.com/callinamagician/472025-radio-not-radio/

Expand full comment
Dave Moore's avatar

A good sign when I think “ooh I like this one” to the song that I already put on a mix! This is great

Expand full comment